Canadian Women in the 26th Lammy Finalists: Some Enthusiastic Rants, and Some Just Plain Enthusiasm

It’s that time of year again: lammy nominations!  Oh, how I love and hate them.  At best, I have complicated feelings about the Lambda Literary Awards.  As Autostraddle writer Carolyn reported last year, in 2004 (!!!) a transphobic book made it onto the trans lit shortlist; it was only removed after protests.  Last year when The Collection: Fiction from the Transgender Vanguard, a short story anthology edited by Tom Léger and Riley MacLeod, won in the trans fiction category, it was the first time a trans author had actually won in that category.  Trans and bisexual categories haven’t been around that long, and at times the categories haven’t accurately reflected books that were nominated or even won in them.

six metres of pavementFor example, Toronto writer Farzana Doctor’s lovely novel Six Metres of Pavement won in the lesbian fiction category a few years ago.  I was really excited to see a Canadian writer of colour win this award.  The thing is, the novel is mainly about a romance between two straight, cis people and the protagonist is a man.  There is a secondary queer character, but she is not a lesbian and explicitly rejects the bisexual label (although she dates people of different genders) and prefers the term queer. Is it just me, or should we take it seriously when someone identifies as queer and not lesbian?  Unfortunately, the Lambdas don’t actually even have a category that would reflect the character in Six Metres of Pavement.  The worst thing about this whole fiasco is that it really fucked with my expectations when I picked up this book, and made me enjoy it a lot less than I would have if I had just read it knowing the author was a lesbian.  When it’s called lesbian fiction, I expect there to be lesbians.  That’s not weird, is it?

Them ruining my enjoyment of Six Metres of Pavement and quashing the distinctions between lesbian, bisexual and queer is probably on par with straight author Thrity Umrigar winning the lesbian fiction category last year for The World We Found. The whole debate on whether authors have to self-identify as LGBT or not has been going on for a while; the Lambda foundation have changed their minds about this a few times.  Currently, books have to have ‘significant’ LGBT content to qualify, but authors do not have to identify as LGBT.  As a queer woman, I’m all for people who aren’t queer writing about queer women, as long as they do their research and seriously consider the responsibilities of writing about a minority group you don’t belong to.  However, it pisses me off when there are fantastic books written by queer women in the lesbian fiction category and a book by a straight woman, with one out of four main characters queer-identified, wins instead.  I just think the award should go to a queer author.  Again, that’s not weird, is it?

There’s another nomination this year that I am pretty pissed off about: cis straight author Ian Hamilton’s The Wild Beasts of Wuhan is up for the lesbian mystery award.  As I said in detail in my review of this book, I think it’s sexist, transphobic (both towards trans masculine and feminine folks), and classist.  It brushes aside sexual assault like it’s not a big deal, praises the lesbian protagonist’s normative gender, contains gross, annoying product placement, includes a transmisogynist metaphor, and fails to address racism, sexism, or homophobia while the Chinese-Canadian lesbian detective is travelling the world.  It’s terrible and offensive and just WHY??

canaryOn the negative train still for a second before I switch gears, I am SUPER disappointed Canary by Nancy Jo Cullen didn’t make the shortlist for LGBT debut fiction.  It’s such a fucking awesome collection of short stories, and one of the best queer books I’ve ever read.  I really don’t understand why it didn’t make the cut because it really stole my heart and is so well-written and funny and authentic and weird and smart.  Cullen really nails working class and rural dialogue and does a fantastic job of creating and depicting ordinary people in all their eccentric glory.  People, there’s a gut-busting story about a middle-aged lesbian going for a bikini wax for the first time after her long-term relationship ends and it doesn’t go exactly as she plans and the story is called “Bush.”  Read more of my thoughts here and go get the book!

wanting in arabicAnyway, like I said, complicated at best.  That said, I am really excited about some of the Canadians who are on the shortlists this year.  In particular, the second edition of Winnipeg writer, poet, and academic Trish Salah’s poetry collection Wanting in Arabic is up for a trans fiction award (uh, despite the fact that it’s poetry, not fiction, but let’s put that aside for now).  Wanting in Arabic was originally published in 2002, and it’s been on my reading list for quite some time.  It would actually fit just as well in a lesbian/queer section, yet another issue with the categories.  To be fair, though, books are submitted by authors and/or publishers into specific categories.   I just got a copy out of the library, so expect a review of it soon!  In the meantime, Globe and Mail writer Margaret Christakos had this to say about the book:

Wanting in Arabic is a self-impelled keening for identification with a lost tongue, both that of her father’s Lebanese roots and her own metamorphosis…This indeterminate and determined voice chronicles the trans-self’s journey as a tour et retour de force…. With ethical toughness and carnal ecstasy, Salah’s writing bosoms up every damn dam in the literary waterway.

Trish Salah (photo by Ralph Kolewe, via

Trish Salah (photo by Ralph Kolewe, via

Doesn’t that sound AWESOME?  Salah is also one of the poets included in Troubling the Line: Trans and Genderqueer Poetry and Poetics, edited by T.C. Tolbert and Tim Trace Peterson, which is up for LGBT anthology.  I’ve heard very, very good things about this collection; in particular, one writer friend told me it would “further complicate and torture my definition odyssey.”  Haha.  The unique thing about this anthology is that it includes detailed poetic statements from all of the poets in addition to their poetry, where they address the relationships between language, identification, embodiment, and activism and give a context for their work.  Salah is the only Canadian that I know of so far in this book, but there are probably (hopefully?) some more that I haven’t heard of in there as well.

how poetry saved my lifeTwo west coast authors, Amber Dawn and Andrea Routley, have also been nominated in the lesbian memoir/biography and LGBT debut fiction categories respectively.  Personally, I think How Poetry Saved My Life is a shoo-in.  It’s such an amazing, unique book, that goes from personal essay to stories to erotica to poetry and back and from funny to heart-breaking and everywhere in between.  I love this book so much every time I write about it, I end up using clichés like “everywhere in between” and “I laughed and I cried.”  Plenitude Magazine editor and founder Routley’s Jane and the Whales is uneven like many debuts, and I don’t think Routley and I share a sense of humour, but it is a powerful collection of short stories by a writer with a serious gift for depicting a particular brand of west coast characters in a darkly comic way.

To see a complete list of the Canadians nominated (including men and Canadian women Mel Bossa’s bi men’s romance and Tracey Richardson’s lesbian romance), check out this Quill & Quire list.

About CaseytheCanadianLesbrarian

Known in some internet circles as Casey the Canadian Lesbrarian, Casey Stepaniuk is a writer and librarian who holds an MA in English literature. She lives and works in the unceded territory of the Snuneymuxw First Nation (Nanaimo, BC). Topics and activities dear to her heart include cats, bisexuality, libraries, queer (Canadian) literature, running, and drinking tea. She runs the website Casey the Canadian Lesbrarian, where you can find reviews of LGBTQ2IA+ Canadian books, archives of the book advice column Ask Your Friendly Neighbourhood Lesbrarian, and some other queer, bookish stuff. She also writes for Autostraddle. Find her on Twitter: @canlesbrarian. Some of her old reviews, especially the non-Canadian variety, can be found at the Lesbrary.
This entry was posted in Amber Dawn, Andrea Routley, Anthology, Asian, Canadian, Farzana Doctor, Fiction, Lesbian, News, Poetry, Queer, Rural, Sex Work, Short Stories, South Asian, Trans, Trans Feminine and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Canadian Women in the 26th Lammy Finalists: Some Enthusiastic Rants, and Some Just Plain Enthusiasm

  1. I definitely have mixed feelings about the Lambda Awards as well. (My god, I loathed Six Metres of Pavement. Again, because I thought it was going to be a lesbian book and it about a heterosexual couple. Also, I found it slow, but I’m sure I wouldn’t have been so harsh if I wasn’t expecting a lesbian book.) I just find it silly that they’ve moved towards “Okay, straight can submit if they write about queer people, and queer people can submit even if they’re writing about straight people.” Either specify content or creator, but the mix is weird.

    I don’t know what to feel about straight/cis authors being allowed to submit. Sometimes they hit it out of the park, but at the same time, this is one of the few places that queer authors can be recognized. But then again, shouldn’t we be rewarding fantastic queer stories regardless of author? Is excluding cis/straight authors who are doing the research and putting in the time and creating amazing stories really helping anything?

    • Yeah, I see what you mean. I think cis and/or straight authors who get it right should be rewarded. The thing is, my impression is that those authors are usually rewarded in the mainstream, whereas LGBTQ authors often aren’t. You know, it’s like, wow, it takes such “imagination and creative power” to write about queer people when you’re not queer, what an amazing thing this straight writer did and all the straight critics think it’s so great and they did a great job. It’s the same thing for straight actors who play gay characters; they get so many more props than gay actors do.

      Especially for a category like trans lit where there is so little support for trans writers and there are so few of their stories, it feels totally wrong to give thoes awards to a cis writer.

  2. Pingback: Link Round Up: March 6 – 12 | The Lesbrary

  3. Pingback: There Sure Are a Lot of Great Canadians in the 2015 Lambda Literary Award finalists! | Casey the Canadian Lesbrarian

Let me know what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s