A Review of Mariko and Jillian Tamaki’s THIS ONE SUMMER: A Beautiful, Troubling Young Adult Graphic Novel

This One Summer, a young adult novel by cousins Mariko Tamaki and Jillian Tamaki, is probably the most visually stunning graphic novel I’ve ever read.  Jillian’s (I’ll refer to them by their first names since they share a last one!) art is nothing short of incredible.  I mean, check out these gorgeous blue-purpleish drawings:

1-this-one-summer-opener-580

this-one-summer-windy-dance

1summer2

If we’re talking about how I’d rate this book, I’d give the visual art ten out of ten, no question.  The illustrations capture the easy, free feeling of long summer days when you’re a kid and rural/small town Ontario so perfectly.  As R.J. Edwards said in their review, “If you’re ever talking about masters of the comics artform you should be mentioning Jillian Tamaki.”

This-One-SummerNow, what’s interesting, especially for me, a self-identified word-obsessed person, is that I felt the writing and plot were a bit … underwhelming compared to the illustrations.   I certainly don’t have a problem with the words taking a backseat to the drawings, which I think is definitely what happens in this book.  There are full pages with no words at all, where the drawings were left to tell the story on their own.  But it felt like there was something missing linguistically, that the words weren’t as rich as the pictures, didn’t live up to the pictures.  Let’s see if I can explain.

This book is about two Toronto girls teetering on the edge of teenagehood, spending their summer together at a lake town in Southern Ontario.  Rose is slightly older than Windy, and is feeling that superior sense of maturity and know-it-allness that only someone who is really young can so confidently exude.  Rose feels a bit embarrassed by her friend Windy this summer, especially in front of the 17-year-old boys working at the general store where she and Windy go to pick up candy and horror movies.  By spending so much time at the store, the girls end up being unwitting spectators and detectives in some local teen drama: an unplanned pregnancy.  Rose is also dealing with constant arguments at home, and what seems like a struggle with depression on her mom’s side, although it’s never named.

Mariko Tamaki

Mariko Tamaki

There’s no question that Mariko nails kid and teenager dialogue.  The dialogue is really exactly what young people sound like—not how you think they sound like, but what they really sound like.  Maybe where my hesitation with the writing and plot is that I’m not sure who the audience for this book is.  It feels like the story is suited more to adults than the early teen girls depicted in the novel or even older teenagers.  Maybe it’s that the point of view seems like it’s from an older version of Rose.  But there are some crucial scenes from the adults’ perspective: in particular, one in which Rose and Windy’s moms talk about Rose’s mom’s miscarriage, and about how Rose doesn’t know about it.

I guess one thing that would worry me about giving this book to girls the same age as the characters is some of the realistic, but nasty behaviour that Rose exhibits.  Do you remember that feeling, especially as a girl and young woman with boys, when you wanted to be liked so badly, and you didn’t have the self-confidence yet to be yourself, and you were trying to fit in no matter what?  When you wanted guys and older kids to like you no matter what, even if it meant being someone you’re not, or saying or doing hurtful things to impress them?

Jillian Tamaki

Jillian Tamaki

This is where Rose is: for example, there is some definite slut-shaming that comes out of her mouth, in an effort to protect her older general store crush.  Windy, on the other hand, knows what Rose said was awful, and isn’t blinded by any romantic or sexual feelings.  Windy, in other words, even though she’s still grossed out by boys, is kind of more mature than Rose in some way.  The thing is, the slut-shaming isn’t really addressed, except briefly and timidly by Windy.  Lessons learnt?  It feels more like that issue, as well as other complicated ones, just sit there, heavily.  As an adult, you can interpret them, know what’s happening, and understand that the novel is not condoning what Rose says—but will teen girls get that message? I’m not sure, because they’re so close, or they’re still in that space.

I don’t know, I don’t want to be the grown-up who says, teenagers can’t handle the tough stuff: I know they can handle a lot more than adults give them credit for.  But I worry about girls like Rose, and what they might come away from This One Summer thinking.  This beautiful, but troubling, book.

Advertisements

About CaseytheCanadianLesbrarian

Known in some internet circles as Casey the Canadian Lesbrarian, Casey Stepaniuk is a writer and future librarian who holds an MA in English literature and is currently studying for an MLIS in the unceded territory of the Musqueam, Squamish and Tsleil-Waututh First Nations (Vancouver, BC). Topics and activities dear to her heart include cats, bisexuality, libraries, queer (Canadian) literature, running, and drinking tea. She runs the website Casey the Canadian Lesbrarian, where you can find reviews of LGBTQ2IA+ Canadian books, archives of the book advice column Ask Your Friendly Neighbourhood Lesbrarian, and some other queer, bookish stuff. She also writes for Autostraddle, Book Riot and Inside Vancouver. Find her on Twitter: @canlesbrarian. Some of her old reviews, especially the non-Canadian variety, can be found at the Lesbrary.
This entry was posted in Asian, Canadian, Graphic, Rural, Young Adult and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to A Review of Mariko and Jillian Tamaki’s THIS ONE SUMMER: A Beautiful, Troubling Young Adult Graphic Novel

  1. I think that there is a raw honesty in these characters and that is what makes me very careful who I let read it. In my elementary school library, if you are not in grade seven, you have to get your parent’s permission to read it. Have you read my comments on this book? http://dickenslibrary.blogspot.ca/2014/12/this-one-summer-by-mariko-tamaki-and.html

    • Thanks for sharing your thoughts Cheriee! I like to hear the perspective of a teacher librarian. I especially like this part of what you wrote: “They are caught in limbo between the innocence of their early years, and the inevitable shattering of it as they come of age. It’s in the juxtaposition of their wisdom and naivety as they emulate the vocabulary and actions of the teens and adults around them.”

  2. Naomi says:

    I like your honesty about feeling uncertain as to the audience this book was written for. Before I give it to my daughter, I’ll read it myself! I have heard nothing but good things about it, otherwise.

Let me know what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s